Keuka College, the national leader in experiential, hands-on learning, is a member of the NCAA Division III, ECAC and North Eastern Athletic Conference (NEAC).

The College sponsors 15 intercollegiate programs: men’s soccer, women’s soccer, women’s volleyball, men’s cross country, women’s cross country, men’s basketball, women’s basketball, synchronized swimming, men’s lacrosse, women's lacrosse, baseball, softball, men's tennis, women's tennis, and golf.

The Weed Physical Arts Center is home to four Keuka teams, including the No. 5 nationally ranked synchronized swimming team, intramural program, and various community activities. The Jephson Athletic Complex features Kuhl Field (baseball), a softball field, four soccer/ lacrosse fields, an exercise trial loop, playground, and pavilion.